I’ve watched this scenario unfold too many times, from both sides of the table.
A business hires an agency. There is the kickoff call, client shared their logo and a few links, and said something like “we want to look premium but approachable.” Three weeks later, the first round of work arrives. It’s polished. It’s on time. And it’s devastatingly wrong.
So you client send some feedback. They revise. The client follows up with more feedback. Somewhere around round four, both sides are frustrated, burnt out, and wishing they said yes to someone else.
It’s not because there wasn’t good talent or because they didn’t care. The brief, or the lack of it, was the villain.
So how to brief a marketing agency the best way?
The short answer, in case you’re in a hurry: a good brief covers eight things: who you are, who your customer is, how you sound, how you look, what you’ve already tried, exactly what you need done, what success looks like, and what you can spend. A good agency will ask you about all eight. If yours doesn’t, that tells you something about your agency.
There’s a version of this that puts all the work on you. That’s not what this is.
Extracting a good brief is the agency’s job. An agency that understands the value of a good brief will sit with you, ask uncomfortable questions, send you a detailed questionnaire and walk through references with you. That’s how we work at leatherjacket studio, and it’s what you should expect from anyone you pay.
But even when an agency does everything right, the quality of what you give them shapes the quality of what you get back. Not because you should be doing their job, but because nobody knows your business the way you do. The faster that knowledge reaches them, clearly and honestly, the faster the work starts landing.
Before leatherjacket studio, I worked on the client side. I wrote briefs, received briefs, watched someone on my team give a brief, sat in kickoff calls on the in-house side, and watched great agencies produce mediocre work because vital context was missing. Now I’m on the agency side, and I see a lot of back and forths that could’ve been avoided if only the brief was thorough. This guide is everything I wish both sides had known.
Tell them the honest, unpolished version: what you do, who it’s for, what stage you’re at, what the last twelve months have looked like and where you want to be next. Not your About Us page, and not your elevator pitch.
Your website copy was written to impress customers. A brief is written to inform the people who’ll be speaking for you. Those are different jobs. Your agency needs to know what your business actually does, who it’s for, what stage you’re at (just launched, growing steadily, trying to scale, or pivoting), and what the last twelve months have really looked like.
The unpolished details are often the most useful ones. If your biggest client accounts for 40% of your revenue and you’re nervous about it, that changes how an agency should think about lead generation. If you’re privately planning to move upmarket next year, the brand work you commission today should be heading there already.
What a good agency will ask:
My tip: answer these out loud on a call rather than in writing. People are far more honest when they talk than when they type. Ask your agency to record the call. Your unscripted answers, in your own words, often become the most useful raw material they have.
An agency that skips these questions and jumps straight to deliverables is an agency that will miss the point.
Describe the person who actually makes the buying decision, not a market: their role, company size, problem, objections and why they chose you over a competitor. Then back it up with your customers’ own words from emails, reviews and sales calls.
“Our customers are businesses in the UAE” isn’t a customer description. It’s a geography.
A useful description tells your agency who actually makes the decision to buy, what they care about, what they’re afraid of, what they’ve tried before, and why they chose you over someone else. “Operations heads at mid-sized logistics companies in Dubai, who’ve been burned by software that their warehouse staff refused to use” gives an agency something to write to. “SMEs in the UAE” gives them nothing.
If you sell to businesses, remember that the person who uses your product, the person who signs the cheque and the person who blocks the deal are often three different people. Tell your agency about all three.
What a good agency will ask:
Real customer words. Verbatim. Emails, WhatsApp messages, reviews, sales call recordings, even complaints.
Most clients never think to share these, and they’re some of the best material an agency can work with. The exact phrases your customers use to describe their problem are usually better headlines than anything a copywriter will invent, and they’re exactly the words people type into Google and ask ChatGPT.
If you have a sales team, give your agency thirty minutes with them. Salespeople hear objections every day that founders have long stopped noticing.
Show it instead of describing it. Share brands whose tone you admire, brands whose tone you dislike, examples of your own writing that felt right, and a list of words you never want associated with your brand.
This is where most briefs completely fall apart.
“Professional but approachable” means nothing. “Bold but not aggressive” means nothing. I’ve read those exact phrases in more briefs than I can count, and every brand believes it’s both. Tone of voice only becomes useful when you show it instead of describing it.
Here’s a quick way to see the difference. Take one simple message, “our new feature saves you time,” and imagine it written three ways:
All three could be called “professional but approachable.” Only one of them is you. A brief that helps your agency pick the right one on the first try saves you three rounds of revisions.
What a good agency will ask:
The negative references matter as much as the positive ones. Knowing what you don’t want is half the brief.
My tip: forward your agency five emails or LinkedIn posts you’ve written yourself that felt exactly right. Your own natural voice is usually the best starting point for your brand’s, especially for founder-led businesses. It also matters more than ever now: with AI-generated copy everywhere, a distinct voice is one of the few things a competitor can’t easily copy.
Visual references show an agency what you value in ways words can’t: how you feel about white space, photography, colour and how much text is too much. Share three to five you like with a line on why, at least one you dislike, and all your existing brand assets.
If the work involves design, whether that’s a website, a campaign, social content or a brand identity, references aren’t optional.
But a reference isn’t just “I like how this looks.” It’s a window into what you value. When you share a website you admire, you’re telling your agency how you feel about white space, photography versus illustration, how much text is too much, and whether you lean bold or quiet. Often you’re telling them things you couldn’t have put into words.
The word that matters most is why. “I like Apple’s website” tells an agency very little, because everyone likes Apple’s website. “I like how Apple’s product pages let one big image do the talking, with very little text” tells them a great deal.
What a good agency will ask:
My tip: screenshots beat links. Websites change, and a link you send today may look different by the time the designer opens it. Take screenshots, drop them into a single document, and add one line under each explaining what caught your eye. Thirty minutes of this before the first call can save weeks of back-and-forth.
Yes. Past failures tell an agency what’s already been ruled out and what your audience has already seen. Share what you tried, what you learned, what frustrated you about previous agencies, and access to your data.
This is the section most clients skip, because it feels like admitting failure. Please don’t skip it.
Everything you’ve tried tells your agency something they need to know: what you’ve already ruled out, what your audience has already seen, and what conversations you’ve already had with the market. A campaign that flopped is data. A campaign that flopped and the reason you think it flopped is gold.
I’ve seen agencies confidently pitch an idea that the client had tried and abandoned a year earlier. Nobody had mentioned it. Weeks were lost, and trust took a hit on both sides that it never quite recovered from.
What a good agency will ask:
Memories of past campaigns are useful, but data is better. If you can, give your agency access to Google Analytics, Search Console, your ad accounts and your social media insights, plus any past reports from previous agencies. Even messy data shows what’s been happening, and it gives everyone a baseline to measure future work against.
And be honest about what frustrated you with your last agency. If it was slow replies, vague reports or junior people on your account, say so. A really good agency will tell you upfront whether they can do better, and how.
Honesty here protects you. An agency that doesn’t know your history will repeat your mistakes, on your budget.
A brief should list the specific deliverables you need, whether it’s a one-off project or a retainer, the channels to focus on or avoid, any fixed deadlines, and the name of everyone who has to approve the work.
Be as specific as you can. “We need marketing help” tells an agency nothing. “We need to grow” is a goal, not a brief.
What output are you looking for? A new website? A three-month content plan? A product launch campaign? An SEO strategy? Social media management? A brand identity? If you’re not sure, that’s fine, but say so. “We know leads are down and we don’t know why” is a perfectly good brief. It just calls for a diagnosis before any deliverables.
What a good agency will ask:
That last question matters more than most people think. I’ve seen projects where the founder approved everything, and then a co-founder, a board member or a family partner saw the work for the first time at the very end and asked for it to be redone.
If three people need to sign off, your agency needs to know before they build a timeline, not after the first deadline slips. Better still, get everyone who has a veto into the first briefing call. And agree on one person who collects all internal feedback and sends it as a single, consolidated message. Contradictory feedback from three directions is one of the fastest ways to slow a project down and burn through your budget.
Define success as a measurable target with a starting point and a timeline, such as going from 5 to 30 relevant enquiries a month within six months. “More visibility” and “better content” are not goals.
This is the most important section of any brief, and the one most often left blank.
“More visibility” is not a goal. “Better content” is not a goal. A goal is something you can look at in six months and say: we got there, or we didn’t.
Compare these:
The second version includes a starting point, a target, a timeline and a definition of quality. That’s what makes it measurable.
What a good agency will ask:
Success needs a timeline that fits the work. Paid ads can show results within weeks. SEO usually needs three to six months before it moves meaningfully. A brand identity project succeeds at launch, but its business impact shows up over the following year. If you expect SEO results by month two, you’ll be disappointed, and no brief can fix that. (I’ve written a separate guide on how to measure each marketing service, if you want the detail.)
If you don’t know what success looks like yet, say so. A professional agency will help you define it. But both of you need an answer before the work starts. Without one, there’s no way to tell if it’s working, and no honest conversation to be had when it isn’t.
Yes. An agency that knows your budget can design a realistic plan around it, instead of pitching an ideal scope you’ll later have to cut. Keep media spend and agency fees separate when you share it.
I know. Saying your number first feels like it puts you at a disadvantage. It doesn’t.
An agency that knows your budget can tell you honestly what’s possible within it: where to prioritise, where to be realistic and where the gaps are. An agency that doesn’t know your budget will pitch you their ideal scope, which may have nothing to do with what you can sustain. Then you’ll spend two more meetings cutting the proposal down, and the version you end up with is a watered-down plan rather than one designed for your budget from the start.
Saying your budget isn’t weakness. It’s efficiency.
What a good agency will ask:
That third question trips up a lot of founders. “We have ₹2 lakh a month for marketing” can mean very different things depending on whether ad spend comes out of it. If it does, and the agency’s fee takes most of it, you may be left with too little to spend on the ads themselves for them to work properly. Always clarify which is which.
The fourth question matters too. Some work, like SEO and content, only pays off if it continues for several months. Six months at a sustainable budget will usually do more than two months at an ambitious one.
If you genuinely don’t know what a realistic budget is, ask the agency what your brief would cost to do properly. A good agency will give you a straight answer, and often a smaller first phase to start with.
Prepare a short business summary, a customer description, real customer quotes, tone and visual references, brand assets, past results, access to your data, the deliverables you need, a list of approvers, success metrics and your budget. Here’s the full checklist.
Save this list. Before your first proper call with any agency, try to have these ready:
You won’t have all of it, and that’s fine. Even half of this list puts you ahead of most clients.
Ideally, the agency responds with questions, not a proposal. It pushes back where something is unrealistic, and plays the brief back to you in its own words before any work begins.
A good agency reads your brief and comes back with questions, not a proposal.
They push back on unrealistic timelines. They tell you when your budget doesn’t match your expectations. They ask about the things you didn’t think to mention. They send you a questionnaire detailed enough that filling it in feels slightly uncomfortable, because good questions usually do. And they play the brief back to you in their own words, so you can confirm they’ve understood before any real work begins.
They make the process easy for you, but they make sure nothing important goes unsaid.
Red flags to watch for:
Long enough to cover the eight areas above. For most small and mid-sized businesses, that’s two to five pages plus attachments like references and brand assets. Specific beats long.
A brief comes from you and explains what you need and why. A proposal comes from the agency and explains how they’ll do it, how long it’ll take and what it’ll cost. A good proposal is built on a good brief.
Yes. Send the same short brief to every agency you’re considering, so you can compare their responses fairly. Share the full detail and data access once you’ve chosen one.
The founder or whoever owns marketing, with input from sales and anyone who talks to customers regularly. A good agency will then help you refine it through a questionnaire and a call.
Whenever your goals, audience or offering change. For ongoing retainers, review it at least every six months or at each renewal.
You can use it to organise your notes. But what matters most, like your customers’ words, your history and your goals, has to come from you. A generic brief gets you generic work.
Brief your agency the way you’d onboard a trusted new team member.
Give them context, not just instructions. Tell them what you’re building, not just what you need this week. Tell them what keeps you up at night, what you’re proud of and what you wish your brand felt like.
The more an agency understands about your business, including your history, your customers, your ambitions and your constraints, the better everything gets. Not just the work. The relationship.
The best agency engagements I’ve been part of, on either side, never felt like vendor relationships. They felt like having a team that happened to sit somewhere else. That starts with the brief.
Our first conversation is never a pitch. It’s a questionnaire, a call and a lot of questions, because we’d rather take two weeks to understand your business properly than spend six months fixing what we got wrong at the start.
If you’d like to see what that process looks like, write to us at hello@leatherjacket.studio. And if you’re already working with an agency, send them this article. A better brief will help them too.